
The short answer (read this first)
You are not legally required to make an Italian will just because you own assets in Italy. But if you own Italian property, a separate Italian will can often make the succession simpler and clearer for your heirs. A US will can generally operate on Italian assets, but only after translation, legalization, and formal publication in Italy, and it has to contend with Italian rules, including forced heirship, that have no equivalent in American law.
If you’ve bought a house in Italy, inherited one, or reclaimed Italian citizenship and started building a life there, this is the estate question to settle before it matters. Here’s the reasoning, in plain English.
What happens to your Italian assets when you die
Whatever your will says and wherever it was signed, assets located in Italy (a house, land, an Italian bank account) pass to your heirs through Italian succession formalities: a declaration of succession filed with the Italian authorities, the formal handling of any will by an Italian notary, and re-registration of property into the heirs’ names. (For the process from the heirs’ point of view, see our step-by-step guide to inheriting property in Italy as a US citizen.)
Separate from those formalities is a deeper question: which country’s law governs who gets what. For an American with assets in Italy, that answer is not automatic; it’s a genuine cross-border legal question, and it drives everything else on this page.
Forced heirship (la legittima): the rule Americans don’t see coming
In the United States, testamentary freedom is broad in many situations, though state law sets its own limits, which vary by state. Italian law takes a different approach. Italian succession law reserves fixed shares of an estate (the legittima) to close family members (the spouse and children above all), and those protected heirs can challenge dispositions that invade their reserved shares. A will that says “everything to my second spouse” or “nothing to my estranged son” can collide with these rules where Italian law governs.
Whether, and how far, forced heirship actually reaches your estate depends on the governing-law question above, and that is precisely the analysis to run while you’re planning rather than leave to your heirs to litigate.
Your US will in Italy: generally usable, with real friction
A will validly made in the US is not ignored in Italy: foreign wills are, as a general matter, capable of recognition and effect. The issue isn’t validity so much as friction:
- Translation and legalization. Your US will needs sworn translation into Italian and apostille/legalization before an Italian notary can act on it.
- Formal publication in Italy. The will must go through formal publication (pubblicazione) by an Italian notary before it operates on the Italian estate, an extra layer your heirs manage from abroad, in a hard moment.
- Concept mismatch. US wills are drafted around institutions Italian law doesn’t share (executors, trusts, clauses phrased for US probate), and mapping them onto a system with no US-style probate can create interpretation questions exactly where you wanted certainty.
- Time and cost for your heirs. None of this is impossible; it’s overhead, borne by your family, multiplied by distance and language.
An Italian will covering the Italian assets may reduce some translation, interpretation, and notarial-processing issues, depending on how the cross-border plan is structured: it’s already in Italian, already in a form the notary processes routinely, and already drafted in the system’s own vocabulary.
When a separate Italian will makes sense
In practice, a dedicated Italian will earns its keep when:
- You own Italian real estate. The strongest single case: property is the asset where registry formalities, notarial processing, and clarity matter most.
- Your heirs don’t speak Italian or know the system. The Italian will is a gift of simplicity to them.
- Your US estate plan is trust-heavy or executor-centric. An instrument Italian law digests natively avoids forcing a notary to interpret US drafting.
- Your family situation is exactly the kind forced heirship cares about: second marriages, estranged children, unequal intended shares. Here the Italian will is where the governing-law strategy (below) gets implemented.
Italian wills come in simple forms, including the fully handwritten will (testamento olografo) and the notarial public will (testamento pubblico).
One warning that pays for this whole article: a US will and an Italian will must be coordinated. Standard US wills open with a clause revoking “all prior wills”: signed after your Italian will, it can wipe it out; the reverse can also happen. Two wills work only when each is drafted knowing the other exists, with revocation language scoped to its own country’s assets. This is the single most common do-it-yourself error we see in cross-border estates.
The choice-of-law angle (and why it needs a professional)
European rules on succession allow a person, under certain conditions, to choose the law of their nationality to govern their succession, a choice made in the will itself. For a US citizen with Italian assets, this can potentially mean directing that the law of your US state, rather than Italian law, governs your estate, with real consequences for how much testamentary freedom you keep. Whether and exactly how this election operates for a US national, and how it interacts with the rest of your plan, is a technical determination that has to be made case by case.
This is why “do I need an Italian will?” is really a planning conversation, not a document purchase: the valuable part is deciding which law you want in charge and drafting so it sticks.
Frequently asked questions
Is my American will valid in Italy? Generally, a will validly made in the US can be recognized and given effect in Italy. The practical hurdles are formal: sworn translation, legalization, and publication through an Italian notary before it operates on Italian assets, plus interpretation questions where US drafting concepts don’t map onto Italian law.
Does Italy have forced heirship? Yes. Italian law reserves fixed shares of an estate (the legittima) to close family (the spouse and children above all), and a will cannot freely override those shares where Italian law governs. Whether forced heirship reaches a US citizen’s estate depends on the governing law, which is exactly what cross-border planning determines.
Can I disinherit my children for my Italian property? Under Italian law, children are protected heirs, and dispositions that invade their reserved shares can be challenged. Whether Italian or US law governs your estate is therefore the decisive question, one to answer while planning, not to leave to your heirs to discover.
Can I have both a US will and an Italian will? Yes. For many Americans with Italian assets, a two-will structure can work well, with each will covering its own country’s assets; whether it fits your situation is a case-by-case decision. The two must be drafted in awareness of each other, with revocation clauses scoped so neither cancels the other.
What happens if I die without any will and own a house in Italy? The estate passes under intestacy rules (the law’s default distribution list) as determined by the governing law. Italian intestacy has its own fixed order (spouse, children, then wider family) that may not match US expectations, and the Italian formalities apply to the Italian property regardless. A dedicated guide is coming.
Does an Italian will cover my US assets? In the structure we usually recommend, no: an Italian will is normally drafted to cover the Italian assets only, precisely so it works alongside your US plan instead of colliding with it. Your US will (or trust) continues to govern your US estate. How the two documents should be scoped in your case is part of the planning conversation.
Do I need a notary to make an Italian will? Not necessarily: Italian law recognizes the fully handwritten will (testamento olografo) without a notary, alongside the notarial public will, which offers stronger formality and safekeeping. Which form fits depends on your situation.
Settle it while it’s easy
The people who ask “do I need an Italian will?” are usually the ones who just bought the house, just inherited it, or just got their Italian citizenship recognized: the exact moment when settling the answer is at its simplest, and far easier than leaving it for your heirs to untangle later.
At Coco Ruggeri & Associates, we’re a US-registered Italian cross-border law firm led by an Italian lawyer registered with the Colorado Supreme Court as foreign legal counsel. We review how your US estate plan and your Italian assets interact, advise on whether a separate Italian will serves you, and draft the two sides so they work together instead of against each other, in English, with both legal worlds covered by one professional. Where your plan has tax dimensions, we coordinate with qualified tax professionals.
To discuss your situation, send us a message through the contact form on our website. If you prefer, you can also call us at 1-303-740-2000.
This article offers general information and is not legal advice. Every estate is different: cross-border succession outcomes depend on your specific assets, family situation, and the law governing your estate. We evaluate each case individually before recommending that a will be made or changed.
Last updated: October 2026.
